Couple charged with stealing 10 vehicles from Hamilton business to be released on bonds

The Butler County Sheriff's Office Headquarters and Jail during it's final days of construction in June 2002. GREG LYNCH / STAFF

The Butler County Sheriff's Office Headquarters and Jail during it's final days of construction in June 2002. GREG LYNCH / STAFF

A Hamilton couple is expected to be released from jail on bonds after being charged with multiple counts of vehicle theft — including 10 vehicles.

But as of now, Jason Kosher, 49, and his girlfriend, Nicole Hibbard-Doyle, 32, both of Grand Boulevard, are still in the Butler County Jail accused of stealing cars in the city in May. They were recently indicted this month on 10 counts each of grand theft, all fourth-degree felonies, and breaking and entering, a fifth-degree felony.

Kosher also was charged with safecracking, a fourth-degree felony.

Jason Kosher, 49, of Hamilton, was arrested in May and indicted in July on 10 counts of grand theft, all felony charges, after he and his girlfriend, Nicole Hibbard-Doyle, 32, of Hamilton, allegedly stole 10 cars from a car lot. They were in court on July 23, and are expected to be released on bonds. They are set to appear back in court for either a plea or trial setting on Aug. 27. PROVIDED/BUTLER COUNTY

icon to expand image

Hibbard-Doyle, who is pregnant, was charged with possessing drug abuse instruments, a misdemeanor, and fourth-degree felony drug paraphernalia offenses, but these offenses, as well as breaking and entering, were ignored by the grand jury.

Kosher is set to be released on an $85,000 bond and Hibbard-Doyle on an own-recognizance bond. Part of Hibbard-Doyle’s release is that after she gives birth, they must reside at a facility in Kettering, a Dayton suburb, that cares for babies and mothers exposed to addictive substances and can only travel to court, the doctor or her attorney. After completing care offered by the Kettering center, she must live with her mother and not leave Butler County except for medical purposes.

However, until their next court appearance in a month, Kosher and Hibbard-Doyle are required to report to Butler County Pretrial Services, will be subject to random drug screenings and must wear an electronic GPS monitoring device.

Nicole Hibbard-Doyle, 32, of Hamilton, was arrested in May and indicted in July on 10 counts of grand theft, all felony charges, after she and her boyfriend, Jason Kosher, 49, of Hamilton, allegedly stole 10 cars from a car lot. They were in court on July 23, and are expected to be released on bonds. They are set to appear back in court for either a plea or trial setting on Aug. 27. PROVIDED/BUTLER COUNTY

icon to expand image

According to the Hamilton Police Department, sometime between 9:30 p.m. May 28 and 4 a.m. May 29, multiple thefts happened at Ardi Auto Imports, 1685 S. Erie Blvd. The suspects came to the car lot and forced open the side door, the police report said, and left with a set of vehicle keys, Ohio dealer tags, a business computer and 10 vehicles. Police also reportedly found drugs and drug paraphernalia.

Officers, who were in an unmarked vehicle, found Kosher and Hibbard-Doyle after seeing one of the stolen vehicles parked in an alley behind Franklin Street in Hamilton. They followed the vehicle, which was later parked at a gas station on Millville Avenue.

When they approached the vehicle, Hibbard-Doyle was in it, while Kosher was “hiding inside the beer cooler inside the gas station.”

Officers said Hibbard-Doyle, who was visibly pregnant, “had been fleeing from officers (for) the past several days” and she had been “observed in the vehicle every time.” She also has warrants out of the Hamilton Municipal Court.

Kosher and Hibbard-Doyle’s cases are being heard by Butler County Common Pleas Judge Noah Powers, and they are expected to be back in court at 8:30 a.m. Aug. 27 where they will either enter a plea or set a trial date.

About the Author